Search found 14 matches

by Gwydion
2012-11-14
Forum: Proposal Discussion
Topic: Summaray of EB Passage for 2nd Half 2012
Replies: 1
Views: 1812

Re: Summaray of EB Passage for 2nd Half 2012

I know that the rules have been defined both on the field and on here. But could you please post them again or direct me to where they are already posted on the forum? Thanks I just want to have a place that I can reference them.
by Gwydion
2012-11-12
Forum: Proposal Discussion
Topic: New Amor System - Play Test Comments
Replies: 57
Views: 23976

Re: New Amor System - Play Test Comments

So back to the armor discussion... : ) With even more play testing how are people feeling about it? The Crown War was weird because we reverted to the old rules. Which really threw me off during the fighting btw. Since we have been playing with the new rules does everyone agree that the new system i...
by Gwydion
2012-11-09
Forum: Proposal Discussion
Topic: Shield Breaking Hits Reduction
Replies: 16
Views: 7071

Re: Shield Breaking Hits Reduction

Is there any way possible this could be play tested on the scale of Inox's armor proposal? I think the current atmosphere of simply disagreeing without seeing it in action is pretty deplorable. At this point both arguements are somewhat opinion based. Lets see if actually play testing it yields any ...
by Gwydion
2012-11-09
Forum: Proposal Discussion
Topic: Shield Breaking and White Axes
Replies: 6
Views: 3431

Re: Shield Breaking and White Axes

That's not true there is a way to track damage from white axes vs great axe/weapons... It has already been discussed else where. I think the problem with this proposal is that it makes it more difficult to track because a ratio of 5 white to 3 black returns us to a decimal half hit system that our c...
by Gwydion
2012-11-08
Forum: General Forum
Topic: Crown War - Aftermath
Replies: 23
Views: 8979

Re: Crown War - Aftermath

@ Thrush Glad you remembered that fight it was good yet brief and inconclusive. I liked how both sides kind parted I turned to my left and there you were. Kinda like some weird video game boss fight or end of movie duel. Haha. Anyway. I think you had me beat I got a hit or two in but you stripped my...
by Gwydion
2012-10-24
Forum: Proposal Discussion
Topic: Open Discussion on Buckler and Destoryed Shield Text
Replies: 28
Views: 10792

Re: Open Discussion on Buckler and Destoryed Shield Text

Good simple fix by forcing bucklers to be attached to the forearm and only allowing one I like it!
by Gwydion
2012-10-23
Forum: Proposal Discussion
Topic: Fighter Ability: Shield Breaking
Replies: 51
Views: 19801

Re: Fighter Ability: Shield Breaking

What is the point of having a proposal discussion board/thread if you are unable to discuss and change the proposals?
by Gwydion
2012-10-23
Forum: Proposal Discussion
Topic: Fighter Ability: Shield Breaking
Replies: 51
Views: 19801

Re: Fighter Ability: Shield Breaking

Lots of good discussion going on here.... @ Shroom Good call on making propsoing the idea of bucklers being able to take two white hits or one black. That is a very simple and common sense solution. Also like you mentioned it parallels the current revision in our armor system that we are currently o...
by Gwydion
2012-10-22
Forum: Proposal Discussion
Topic: Fighter Ability: Shield Breaking
Replies: 51
Views: 19801

Re: Fighter Ability: Shield Breaking

I like the idea of white axes taking four hits instead of three. I would also like to increase the ability of glaives and black axes to destroy shields quicker prompting more of their use. I would like to see them destroy shields in 2 hits. That will actually make shield breaking worthwhile for them...
by Gwydion
2012-10-22
Forum: Proposal Discussion
Topic: Fighter Ability: Shield Breaking
Replies: 51
Views: 19801

Re: Fighter Ability: Shield Breaking

Another problem with having halberds and battle axes with shield breaking is that its a neat ability for them but especially for battle axes which don't have the reach it isn't really effective. When confronted with shield breaking weapons its very easy to move your shield out of the way block with ...
by Gwydion
2012-10-22
Forum: Proposal Discussion
Topic: Fighter Ability: Shield Breaking
Replies: 51
Views: 19801

Re: Fighter Ability: Shield Breaking

Realistically the rule should also be applied to white axes as well. Game wise it would add to the variety of weapons we see on the field. RIght now I very rarely see any white axes because they are heavier and unwieldy compared to a sword and do not give any additional benefit. Check out this link ...
by Gwydion
2012-10-15
Forum: Proposal Discussion
Topic: New Amor System - Play Test Comments
Replies: 57
Views: 23976

Re: New Amor System - Play Test Comments

Lord Valfryn, I disagree about your idea of incrementally introducing a three tiered system after this passes. If this passes the major problems with the current system will have already been fixed. It will not be as big a problem and there will be no reason/determination to fine tune and refine the...
by Gwydion
2012-10-13
Forum: Proposal Discussion
Topic: New Amor System - Play Test Comments
Replies: 57
Views: 23976

Re: New Amor System - Play Test Comments

Inox, Trust me I love the fact that the new armor system reduces the effectiveness of flails. If I had my way flails wouldn't be head legal. But I understand that will never happen and I will also never consider even bringing it up as a serious proposal. My mentioning of dying to flail really had no...
by Gwydion
2012-10-13
Forum: Proposal Discussion
Topic: New Amor System - Play Test Comments
Replies: 57
Views: 23976

Re: New Amor System - Play Test Comments

Land searches are really not a good way to play test the new armor system. They are a completely separate dynamic of the game. It doesn't really translate well into how battle days and combat during adventures between PC vs PC take place as opposed to land searches and combat between PC vs NPC take ...